Clash of the Titans
When done correctly , an natural action film think of its hearing with well - choreograph thrills and a naked , never - tell - me - the - odds heat , while providing a sassy , compendious looking into human nature . This strain of natural process films was insanely popular in the ' 80s and ' 90s thanks to big - projection screen mavin like Arnold Schwarzenegger and Sylvester Stallone .
More recently , the rise of the superhero genre has conduct to something of a conversion for the actioner , and , with Hollywood relying more and more on remaking to lasso in moviegoers , several definitive actioners — concentre on everything from martial graphics to Greek mythology — have been recreated for modernistic audience . Sometimes these reimaginings offer an updated dangerous undertaking that can even surpass the original in terms of quality , while other times they ’re created entirely to capitalize on the anterior film ’s winner , causing them to be poorly made and create audience gulf .
Worst: Clash of the Titans
In 1981 , acclaimed animator Ray Harryhausen andJason and the Argonautsproducer Charles Schneer get together onClash of the Titans , a picture establish on Hellenic mythology . The " princess and dragon " fighter pursuance sport Zeus ’s son Perseus earned decisive extolment for its visual effects and old - school charm , so it ’s understandable that MGM saw " cash cow " potential in a remake of the beloved classic . When it was bring out in 2010 , however , the remaking receive extremely negative review . critic said it just did n’t last up to the nostalgia , citing the bothersome visual effects and sterile hand . Despite the poor reception , however , the cinema gross nearly$500 millionworldwide and was followed by a continuation , Wrath of the Titans , two yr later .
Best: 3:10 to Yuma
In the 1957 film3:10 to Yuma , place in Wild - West - era Arizona , Volunteer are needed to escort bewitch deplorable Ben Wade onto the train to Yuma Prison . Dan Evans , a rancher in demand of money , agrees to the proposition in exchange for $ 200 . The premiss remains the same in the 2007 remake , although many regard the remake animprovement on the originalas well as one of the best Western of the 21st one C , pointing to the memorable acting , rugged action succession , and misanthropical creative thinking .
Despite receiving all this praise ( and twoAcademy Awardnominations ) , it was still unsuccessful at the box berth , hit just $ 70 million on a $ 55 million budget .
Worst: Poseidon
Before James Cameron’sTitanicreinvigorated the catastrophe picture show writing style , 1972’sThe Poseidon Adventurefollowed rider and crew on the fictitious SSPoseidonattempting to escape the capsized sumptuosity liner . The star - studded picture achievedmajor furore statusand win two Academy Awards , and even the least enthusiastic critics branded it " so bad it ’s estimable . " So it was only natural that the film would receive a remaking , Poseidon , released by Warner Brothers in 2006 . However , while critics commendedPoseidon ’s use of photorealistic CGI , the ocular effect could n’t make up for the shaky storytelling and forgettable action sequences . In the end , itwas just a useless remaking that should n’t have been made .
Best: The Mummy
1999’sThe Mummy — arguably the well - known celluloid in the enfranchisement — was actually a remake of a lesser - known 1932 movie with the same name starring repugnance legend Boris Karloff . The more recent version , despite find motley review at its button , has since been admit as a pivotal movie in the chronicle of action horror . Brendan Fraser ’s performance as the quintessential activity fighter has been specially praised , and , despite not being as well - find as its pre - Code predecessor , The Mummyis still a macabre classic that exchange its genre for the better . The2017 Tom Cruise reboot , though ? Not so much .
Worst: Death Wish
Back in 1974,Death Wishshocked the world with its sanguineous tale of an architect who snatch up after his wife is murdered by home invaders , do him to start out kill muggers and other violent criminals in the streets . The celluloid attracted contention for its unmistakable championing of vigilante justness , although , with offense rates rising during the mid-’70s , the film definitely resonated with audience and was an important part of action picture show history . 2018’sDeath Wish , on the other paw , was much more poorly received , with critics complaining that it remove all the effectiveness and context of the original and instead replace it with momentary thrills and an inane tincture . Oddly enough , general consultation were more accepting of the film , with coarse themes among positive review being the film ’s action and emotion .
Best: 13 Assassins
Probably the least well - known film on this list,13 Assassins , a 2010 samurai flick based on veridical - spirit events , received irresistibly positive review from critics . It ’s a remake of the 1963 period dramatic event of the same name , but boasts a higher budget than its predecessor and was in general believe well by critic .
The film is about the titular 13 assassinator who contrive to assassinate a cruel Nipponese ruler to foreclose him from being appointed to a powerful council of feudalistic lords . Critics waxing lyric about the film applaud its ability to fulfil acute activeness scene while not forgetting about developing its plot and quality , and many commended the conclusion of the film ( a wondrously pip 45 - minute scrap fit that we can only assume was a logistical nightmare to make ) .
Worst: Total Recall
Arnold Schwarzenegger is one of the most successful action stars of all time — and a good deal of that success is thanks toTotal Recall . The 1990 action film focalise on a construction worker ( Schwarzenegger ) who realise his entire memory has been planted in his brainpower and must discover what ’s literal and what ’s not . It was still a box post success and even receive a Special Achievement Academy Award for its visual effect . With ' 80s nostalgia becoming an progressively lucrative venture , a remaking was finally released in 2012 — to critical panning . Common complaints criticized the remake ’s lack of patch , temper , and character development compare to the original . To many , it was just another example of Hollywood ’s aggressive nostalgia - baiting .
Best: The Departed
In the 2006 filmThe go away , organise by Martin Scorsese , a gangster who ’s been plant in the police force force square off against a police officer who ’s been planted in his ring . Hijinks result , as each must unveil the other without being key himself . The film was a box - office success and received extremely positive reviews from critics for its epic and gritty storyline , with many heel it as one of the good motion picture of Scorsese ’s career . It also won the Academy Award for Best Picture . However , it’sactually a remakeof a picture show that ’s much less well - eff in the cinephile community — the 2002 Hong Kong filmInfernal Affairs , which alike received Brobdingnagian critical praise .
Worst: Point Break
" cyberspace ’s young man " Keanu Reevesjump - started his action film career with 1991’sPoint Break . The film , which has since achieved " rage film " condition , sport an FBI factor ( Reeves ) who form a confusing family relationship with a surfing crew of money box robbers he ’s tasked to look into . overconfident reviews often focused on the pic ’s raw " coolness " and horrific action scenes , and the film had enough of a ethnic wallop to be finally remade in 2015 .
unluckily , the remaking received intense critical disdain , with not even the imposingly coordinate stunts saving it from what critics comprehend as poor casting and a lack of humour .
Best: King Kong
Peter Jackson had been trying for age to remake 1933 ’s masterpieceKing Kong , and in 2003 he finally got his chance . The success of hisLord of the Ringsfilms persuaded studio apartment psyche into pursuing the project , with the film being granted one of the high-pitched yield budgets of all time . When it was released in 2005 , criticsheaped praiseupon the magnificence and scale of measurement of the remake as well as Jackson ’s counselling . The film ’s portrayal of the Greco-Roman paradigm of Kong atop the Empire State Building was especially fear . Unlike several other remakes on this list , this film is an example of offer echt nostalgia because the God Almighty was passionate about the labor , rather of just operate as a cash grab .
NEXT:5 ' 90s activity Movies That Did n’t Age Well ( & 5 That Only Got good )
