Related
The space fantasy phenom be intimate asStar Warshas recapture the aid of fans , between the release of the epicJedi : diminish Ordervideo game from EA andThe Mandalorianfrom Disney+ . Perhaps most significantly , though , is the anticipated conclusion to the sequel trilogy , Episode IX : The Rise of Skywalker , determine to reach theaters next week . The photographic film looks to be a thrilling - or at least an interesting - climax for our heroes Rey , Poe , and Finn .
Yet , 14 years ago , all of theStar Wars - associate plug was centered around the conclusion to the Lucas - madeprequeltrilogy , which promised a spellbind tale revolve about around Anakin Skywalker ’s transformation and rise as the iconic baddie Darth Vader . Unlike the first 2 films of the prequel trilogy which are more universally panned , Episode III : Revenge of the Sithtends to produce sundry reaction . While many take care back fondly on this darker , more dramaticStar Warsstory , it run to get slagged just as much .
Related : Star Wars : 5 Reasons Why We Want The hike Of Skywalker To Be The terminal Of The Saga ( & 5 Reasons We Do n’t )
We ’ll undertake to make gumption of it all and make the case for why this film is underrated , in addition to why it might be given a bit too much credit .
Overrated: Some Boring, Static Scenes
For a film that covers the turbulent period of the Old Republic as it descends into darkness , as well as Anakin ’s shift to Vader , it can certainly drag out on with some boring second . Lucas and McCallum gratefully decided to dial back much of the tardily - paced , cheesy love story between Anakin and Padme this prison term around .
Yet , we ’re still given quite a few electrostatic scenes have some confutable lines ( and rail line deliveries ) , juxtaposed in - between some far more entertaining activity scene . We get some pointless , drawn - out , and some rather cringe - worthy exchange throughout . Although this film does contain more bouts of interest than , say , Attack of the Clones , that ’s not say much .
Underrated: A Darker, Edgier Star Wars
In stark contrast to the first two prequel films , particularly the lighthearted and even goofyEpisode I , Lucas put the centering on action , drama , and the disconsolate undertones of both the force and social club at large with this conclusion .
This plastic film , which was the first of theStar Warssaga to incur a PG-13 rating , kept a larger consultation captivate with some higher wager and overall more acute , worked up moments throughout . Its heavier intension and dramatic moment contribute a sense of depth , allow for you to get more invest in these characters and this complex lodge .
This tended to compliment the story far better than , say , The Phantom Menace , which matte up like a film for untried kids with a far more intricate political assumption which jar with its tone .
Overrated: An Excess Of Lightsaber Duels
It probably break without state that one ofStar Wars ' great appeals is its unique lightsaber weaponry . These almost inherently produce some visually fun fight scenes thanks to the mesmeric glow and buzzing of these sci - fi sword . Yet , Lucas perhaps put a bittoomuch religion in the draw and merit of these optical maser swords , fill the screentime with dozens of bombastic lightsaber duels feature over - the - top stage dancing .
Related : Star war : 10 Coolest Jedi From The Prequel Trilogy
It ’s hard to make a casing for a lightsaber typeface - off lastingseveral minutesat the conclusion of this flick , evenwiththe worked up weight behind Anakin and Obi - Wan ’s major duel . You just begin to get dead to the unceasing clashing of lightsabers , especially after minutes of seemingly no advancement being made .
Underrated: Some Thrilling Action
Still , you ’ve get to appreciate the level of grandiloquence and action elsewhere inRevenge of the Sith , between the thrill General Grievous conflict , the warmness - breaking Order 66 execution , and the sprawling struggle between the Republic Clones and Separatists . And hey , even the lightsaber fights this film so often leans oncanbe telling inshortbursts .
The action is at an all - sentence high in terms of visual gaudiness and emotional system of weights here . substantial event arefinallyin motion and the Republic itself hangs in the residuum , as does that of the progressively powerful Anakin . Episode IIIdoes a grand job of showing these chaotic and important case wreak out overall .
Overrated: Feels Segmented
WhileEpisode IIItends to accentuate a more in darkness - tint sense of drama more often than not , there exist a strange clash of styles . The moving picture seems to vibrate between Shakspearean drama , cheesy Saturday morning cartoon , and a darker , more wild action movie . Furthermore , the setting and overall fashion ofRevenge of the Sithtakes on a spirit of being all over the plaza .
The more cartoonish sensibilities that open up this moving picture on Grievous ' ship seemworldsapart from the ending of the movie , which seems to desperately endeavor to recapture the mere , more somber circumstance of the start of 1977’sA New Hope .
Underrated: The Emperor At His Best
Sometimes a character can produce such a strong , stand up - out performance that he or she can practically carry the pic on their own meritoriousness . This is partially the case with Ian McDiarmid , whose personation of Palpatine / Lord Sidious is in top form throughoutRevenge of the Sith . His speech and overall demeanor are just dripping with evil , and his dynamical playing injects some life into a film that definitely needs it at clip .
Related : Rise Of Skywalker : 10 Questions On Kylo Ren , Palpatine , And Other villain We Want Answered
His cunning and ability to mastermind an derangement of the largest government in the galaxy makes the viewer more than a little uneasy about this villain . You get a sentiency of mania and emotion with this sinister , sadistic Sith throughout .
Overrated: Weak Villains Elsewhere
It ’s problematical to believe someone like Sidious can occupy the same flick as the over - the - top , neckcloth , and cartoonish antagonist that is General Grievous , or the increasingly naive and unpointed fissiparous leadership like Nute Gunray .
And while actor Hayden Christensendoescertainly bring some passion to his characterization of a young Vader , eventhisiconic villain ’s impact and depth is passably diminished here with his frequent complaining and whining . This Jedi - work - Sith is more reminiscent of a downtrodden stripling with a grudge rather than the icy , menacing wraithlike form that Darth Vader is present to be in the original trilogy .
Underrated: A Nice Bridge Between The Prequels And Original Trilogy
Though the changeover in preferences and tone can run to sense sharp follow the showdowns between the Jedi and Sith , Lucasdoesmanage to reestablishEpisode IIIas the fitting prequel it ’s mean to be . This is achieved by the elaborated and entertaining showcasing of the series of events that lead up to the weather condition that kick offA New Hope . It ’s one of the few times this trilogy , which almost take on the intuitive feeling of being in anotheruniverse , truly feels connected to the authoritative trilogy , and serves as a squeamish institution to the old film for younger fans .
Overrated: A Weak Plot
Given the sky - high-pitched stakes and important consequence that bring us from Anakin to Vader ; from Republic to oppressive Empire , Episode IIItends to fall flat more often than not in terms of its tale . confutable actions , flaws in logical system , and some erratic tempo comprise much of this film , to the dot where it can be difficult to bide invested .
How could Anakin so easily yield to the dark side when even Palpatine warned of the astronomic chances of saving Padme with these powers ? What was with Palpatine / Sidious apparently allowing himself to be captured by Grievous ? How could so many force play - channeling Jedi be so oblivious to the conspiracy of the Sith ? These and other questions diffuse this otherwise entertain photographic film .
Underrated: Some Neat Special Effects And Cinematography
While the original trilogy - and to a lesser degree , thesequel films- cohere to a panache more grounded in reality , this film goes full - throttle valve with special core and cinematic glitz . While it ’s been criticized for its bombast and its less organic style , it ’s these effects that help set the stage for a grandiose narrative and put forward the imagination . The variety of the fat configurations , from the overgenerous Wookie planet to the ominous Mustafar system , celebrate affair feel unfermented and interesting .
And unlikeEpisode IandII , the level of contingent here , coupled with some large depth and a darker vibration , makeRevengefeel more like an epic cinematic experience and less like a video game .
Next : Star Wars : The 10 Cringiest mo From The Prequel Trilogy
