Treasure Planet
They ’re two of Disney ’s most underrated animated feature , they ’re sci - fi epics that separate the fandom down the middle , they make us desire to either soar to the mavin or submerge to a sunken city . Of course , we ’re talking aboutAtlantis : The Lost EmpireandTreasure Planet . One is an original steampunk adventure , the other is a retro - futurism reimagining . But which one is better ?
That is the query we plan to suffice today . After look at both picture show , we ’ve collect a list of elements they both partake in to feel out who outdoes who . Will it be Milo Thatch and the metropolis of Atlantis , or Jim Hawkins and Flint ’s Trove ? Read on and find out .
Best Origins: Tie
This was kind of a hard conclusion because whileTreasure Planetis inspired by one of the greatest works of fiction in existence , the story of Atlantis does n’t just have one definite seed . At the end of the day , it all comes down to a subject of mouthful . Do you desire something realistic or fabulous ?
As far as being accurate to thesource material , Atlantisreferences its inspiration more . ButTreasure Planetgives new living to a well - sleep with preferent story . It all roil down to how much change is palpable to the audience . In the end , we really just ca n’t decide .
Best Story: Tie
Where we could n’t determine on the last point because the two are just two different , we tie them up again on this one because they ’re remarkably similar . call back about it , both narrative are focused on sashay in large ships with mutinous crews to discover a lost hoarded wealth . The main difference is the size of the prize .
For the work party ofAtlantis , it ’s the Heart of Atlantis . For Silver and his face pack of quad - pirate , it ’s the Loot of a Thousand Worlds . The biggest wedge between the two of them is how they fulfil the feat , but that ’s why we have this leaning .
Best Style: Atlantis
We can already find some of you turn on us now , but hear us out . The only reasonAtlantisgets the point is because it persist the most uniform . We love the nuclear fusion reaction of stylus that make the movie so distinct , however , Treasure Planethas the riding habit of getting things a trivial too one - sided in its designs .
Why have galvanic / solar technology in a world that still use natural gas lamps and coal stoves ? It ’s a nitpick , maybe , but one we could n’t overlook . The tip goes toAtlantisfor sticking with likely applied science for the 1914 - inspired macrocosm it address home .
Best World: Treasure Planet
WhereAtlantisgives us one of the most beautiful and somewhat alien continents we ’ve ever seen , Treasure Planetgives us an entire macrocosm to enjoy . If you want to talk about alien worlds , there are few as various or as interesting as the Montressor Space Port , not to observe the various races that make up the crew of the Legacy .
gem Planettakes the daub because it plainly just volunteer more . liken a continent to a whole universe of weird and wonderful puppet and characters and which would you choose ? Point toTreasure Planetfor giving us more to work with .
Best Performances: Atlantis
Atlantis’svocal performance can be summed up in one word , infectious . From Michael J Fox as the irritable Milo Thatch to Cree Summer as the enchanting Kida , the talent behind these animated characters is rock solid . Not that we ’re knockingTreasure Planet’scast at all , butAtlantis’scast is simply sturdier .
The drawback ofTreasure Planet’sperformances is that some of the characters palpate like a celebrity behind a microphone instead of an existent character , mostly due to Joseph Gordon Levitt ’s Jim Hawkins and Martin Short ’s B.E.N. In Atlantis , however , the performances palpate less like actor and more like the eccentric characters that bring the story to life .
Best Heroes: Atlantis
Both expedition teams have some colorful quality and memorable heroes , but if it ’s down to a one on one compeer , the winner is old Milo Thatch . Jim Hawkins definitely has a lot going for him , but we got ta go with brainiac over roguish attitude . The cause ? Milo ’s geeky character is more grounded than Jim ’s futurist forged boy part .
Jim is a character we ’ve seen over and over again , a bleak - cap - wearing troublemaker with daddy issues and a heart of gold . Milo , on the other hand , is n’t just your distinctive nerd , he ’s a professional in his field . He desire to go on this military expedition for skill , not for nimbus . He ’s solid , original , and takes the point .
Best Villains: Treasure Planet
Now how do you do aTreasure Islandretelling without a swarthy gang of swashbucklers to jell sail with ? Where the original seized the ship with cutlasses in their tooth , Disney ’s sci - fi reimagining trades in the flintlock pistols for laser blasters and cybernetic implants . They ’d certainly creamAtlantis’sgang of graverobbers and looters .
Do n’t get us ill-timed , Commander Rourke and his army of goons unquestionably put up a competitiveness against Milo and his friends , but they ’re just not as memorable as Silver , Scroop , and the various alienpiratesthat take over the Legacy . It ’s a pirate ’s life for us , we ’re afraid .
Best Side Characters: Atlantis
Although we do have a special place in our spunk for Captain Amelia and Doctor Doppler , the crew of the Ulysses just has more to offer . From Mr. Whittmore to Moliere , the patronize cast ofAtlantisdefinitely has more personalities and offbeat characters to find fault from . It ’s definitely both lineament and quantity in this case .
Aside from the previously mentionedTreasure Planetcharacters , how many can you greet by name ? A groyne - like buster with a elephantine drill , easily Moliere . Brooklyn Italian guy with an telling mustache and interest in dynamite , obviously Vinnie . We could go on and on , but we think the point is made .
Best Humor: Treasure Planet
Both movies have their own brand of humor , do n’t get us wrong . But as far as which has more ha - ha humourous second , it ’s hoarded wealth major planet , no dubiety about it . Atlantishas its instant , but its focal point is more on the mystic steampunk - tincture expedition to the metropolis of Atlantis than produce us laugh .
This motion-picture show has all the slapstick , one - liner , and visual humor we ’ve do to ask from a distinctive Disney romp . But it ’s where some of the contrast come from that surprise us . Captain Amelia , though tight - laced and professional has some of the best lines in the film . And do we even need to mention the farting foreign ?
Winner: Atlantis (By One)
This was a really close match and hear as we might , we just could n’t make it a sleeper game . As much as we adoreTreasurePlanetfor its fusion of vogue , its lovable exotic characters , and it ’s sci - fi reimagining of a classical sea robber ’s tale , we ’re looking at the overall moving-picture show . Atlantistakes the pate .
What can we say but we have it away the traditional Disney sketch block panache of animation , the steampunk elements that are both fantastic and likely even for 1914 , and the admixture of sci - fi and fantasy report ? It ’s definitely our favorite underrated Disney gem .
NEXT:10 Ways Disney ’s Atlantis : The Lost Empire is a Sci - Fi chef-d’oeuvre
