Related
The scrappedBatman Triumphanthad some lofty ambitions ; none more so than its purport change to Harley Quinn ’s bloodline story.1997’sBatman & Robinstarring George Clooneyas the titulary chiropteran - botherer is unfondly remembered as comfortably the bad cinematic adventure for the Caped Crusader . Aside from the unflinchingly corny dialogue and to a fault - cartoonish aesthetic , sports fan take elision to Joel Schumacher ’s depiction of once - formidable villains Mr. Freeze and Bane , both of whom were , purposely or otherwise , more comedic than threatening . Nevertheless , design were already underway for a third SchumacherBatmanmovie .
Although the project was ultimately scrap , the initial thought forBatman Triumphantwould’ve featured the united trio of Batman , Robin ( Chris O’Donnell ) and Batgirl ( Alicia Silverstone ) necessitate on the villainous duo of Scarecrow and one Harley Quinn . A relatively new addition toBatmancanon at that time , Harley debuted in a 1992 installment ofBatman : The Animated Seriesand made a typically insistent impression . Harley would go on to become a staple fiber of theBatmanuniverse and is currently play on cinema byMargot Robbie , who has pull in plenty of acclaim for her eccentric performance . Batman Triumphant ’s Harley Quinn would ’ve been radically different from both Robbie ’s , and the traditional character .
Related : Batman Returns : What Happened To Marlon Wayans ’ Cut Robin
Warner Bros ' line up Mark Protosevich to write theBatman Triumphantscript and planned to give Harley Quinn a drastic career modification , shifting from psychiatric medicinal drug to the Earth of toymaking . Rather than Joker ’s doting lady friend , this small craftswoman would ’ve been the occult daughter of Jack Nicholson ’s gone Clown Prince fromTim Burton ’s 1989Batman . After discovering her heritage and the destiny of her sire , Protosevich ’s former drawing had Harley embark on a revenge commission against Batman , teaming up withBatman Triumphant ’s other baddie , Scarecrow , who was also gun for Bruce Wayne . plunge herself in the same Ace Chemicals tub her Church Father fall into was supposedly another mooted idea on the table for Harley .
At the very least , Protosevich ’s ideas for Harley Quinn are challenging . Schumacher anticipate any furtherBatmanmovies he channelize would be dingy , and gear towards a more matured audience . The idea of a tardy 1990sHarley Quinnin that particularBatmansandbox had the potential drop to be a hothead , eclectic thrill ride , with Harley better suited to Schumacher ’s outrageous neon Gotham City than say , Bane . Even so , the proposed change to Harley ’s origin would ’ve almost certainly strut some plume .
Being Joker ’s daughter , rather than an obsessed lover , is undoubtedly the biggest deviation , and one that for the most part hinge on the on-going argument over whetherTim Burton’sBatmanmoviesare connected to Schumacher ’s . There are arguments to both sides , but if Warner Bros. take a firm stand on maintaining a 5 - film persistence , making Harley Jack Napier ’s daughter would be the most logical resolution . As weird as the variety would experience , the familial link would also work out the issue of introducing Harley without the presence of Joker . In term of Harley ’s civilian past times , working as a toymaker is in - keeping with her general carnival musical theme and adds a slenderly creepy touch to the scoundrel , but her original backstory as a deranged former Arkham psychiatrist has far more machination , while also establishing Harley as a viable threat to Batman due to her intelligence agency .
Batman Triumphant ’s vision of Harley Quinn piques the interest , despite being a mark departure from her traditional portrayal . render howBatman & Robinpanned out , however , it ’s possible that the reimagined Harley ( who feel quite bewitching on paper ) might not have seamlessly interpret into alive - action , specially since one lead name reportedly being considered for the role was Madonna . Though she remain without a live - action mechanism coming into court for many years , Harley Quinnis an everlastingly popular mainstream figure in 2020 , peculiarly at Halloween , and this perhaps would n’t have happen ifBatman Triumphanthad done to Harley whatBatman & Robindid to … everyone .
More : Batman : Every Live - Action Wayne Murders Scene ( And How Bruce ’s Origin Changes )
