Related
ThoughBlack Widowwill filling in some of theMarvel Cinematic Universe ’s story gaps , it is not out of the region of possibility that Natasha Romanoff ( Scarlett Johansson ) lives on and her " babe " Yelena Belova ( Florence Pugh ) may have actually been the one to make the sacrifice play inAvengers : Endgame . Black Widowwill cover the metre betweenCaptain America : Civil WarandAvengers : Infinity War . This time span may hold up the Florida key to the return of Black Widow to the dealership , despite her death . It hinge on the question of whether or not Yelena , as Natasha , took the fall inEndgame .
The announcement of theBlack Widowfilm was long overdue , 10 year after the graphic symbol ’s enfranchisement unveiling inIron adult male 2 . Although , sports fan were confused about its annunciation follow her death in the fourthAvengersfilm , it has since been discover thatBlack Widowwill be a prequel . It will come Natasha ’s journey back to Russia where her story commence , reuniting with faces from her past , who have been depict asher real first phratry . Among them will be her foster sis , Yelena Belova .
Related : Black Widow hypothesis : [ SPOILER ] Is The undercover Villain
Yelena and Nat went through the mysterious Red Room together , receiving similar training and being fed similar Russian propaganda . They are near equals , understanding each other inside and out . This take a shit themtwo of many Black Widows . Because of this , one could convincingly imitate the other , and it has been hypothesise that somehow Yelena was the one who lived through the event ofInfinity WarandEndgamedisguised as Nat . This would paint a picture that Black Widow is still awake chronologically .
Yelena May Be Given Natasha’s Face In Black Widow
At some point inBlack Widow , Yelena could " borrow " Natasha ’s face , and technology innovate inCaptain America : The Winter Soldiermakes this a possibility . The Photostatic Veil is a man of S.H.I.E.L.D. espionage equipment . When place over the face of the user , s / he takes on the visual aspect of someone else . Natasha used it in the 2014 film to spoil Hydra ’s takeover of S.H.I.E.L.D. masquerade as World Security Council member Hawley ( Jenny Agutter ) . It also see a handful of uses in theAgents of S.H.I.E.L.Dtelevision series .
It is unknown as of now whether or not Photostatic Veils will be inBlack Widow . If so , at some point in the moving picture Yelena could convincingly replicate Nat ’s cheek likely for the sake of their missionary work againstthe enigmatic Taskmaster . There could be some sort of mixing - up that leave in the two trading places from that point on .
What Yelena Being Natasha Would Mean For Avengers: Endgame & The MCU
If this is the case , there are wider implications on the MCU that would have to be addressed . For one , the timing of their electric switch would be a key piece of selective information . Did it occur afterCivil War ? AfterInfinity War ? Some other prison term ? How long was Yelena assuming Nat ’s life ? The answer would make a domino effect of other questions . The culmination of these questions would affect Natasha ’s biggest instant in the franchise : her last inEndgameand the repercussions of her forfeiture for the Soul Stone .
colligate : Avengers : Endgame Deleted Scene unwrap Alternate Black Widow Death ( & It ’s bad )
On the hopeful side , Black Widow would still be alert , and Scarlett Johansson could potentially return to the character in future MCU film . However , the emotional resonance of her last would be mostly lost . Her demise inEndgamealtered the intact story . The original Avengers were in shambles . This is n’t to say Yelena ’s death would n’t be sad , but it mean Natasha ’s choice would be ultimately cheapened , regardless as tohow strangely it arrive off . A hook - and - shift would stain the moving-picture show retroactively .
The Problems With The Yelena-Is-Natasha Black Widow Theory
As far as story issues go , there are plenty to discuss . Narratively , it is incredibly convoluted . For as item - orientate as the MCU can be , this is almost too much . It would undersell Natasha ’s story , coming off as a knee - dork reaction to the fan call for her return . In doing so , it would also squander Yelena ’s potential in the franchise , reducing Florence Pugh ’s part in the MCU to a mere body double . Pugh has try she is worthy of so much more witha well-heeled futurein the franchise . A twist like this would throw all of that out for no just reason .
Logically , this theory is madden . Why would Yelena choose to live Nat ’s animation for so long ? Better yet , where is Natasha for this entire fourth dimension underframe ? Also , its highly improbable she could mimic Nat in every potential way from her effort to her speech rule down to the last microscopic detail . specially troublesome are her memories . Photostatic Veils only work on the surface , not for personality . After years apart , Nat could n’t have possibly say Yelena everything about her post - ruddy Room life story so speedily .
Even if she did draw it off , Yelena would surely be found out by her peers eventually . It ’s a given she ’d have to hit the humeral veil at some point . All it would take is for one person to see her and the whole act would be up . If it is to be accepted that no one noticed , it is an insult to the intelligence of her teammates . In that same vein , it would be a major affront to that of the consultation as well .
Related : Black Widow Theory : All Of Natasha ’s fellowship Are Killed By Thanos
Though it is fun to speculate , it is likely that Natasha and Yelena will keep their faces to themselves . Black Widow isa prequel , so for the time being she remain gone chronologically . Black Widow will see the big cover one more time though , and she is n’t the only Italian sandwich torise from the grave in Phase 4 , as Vision ( Paul Bettany ) and Gamora ( Zoe Saldana ) have been confirmed to appear in future MCU films . Still , untilBlack Widowhits theaters surmise can still operate wild . Could Yelena have taken Natasha ’s case and her selfless moment inEndgame ?
More : Black Widow Theory : Natasha Is nail The Avengers ' Civil War Mission
