Turning a musical comedy into a successful moving picture is no easy feat . A spirit back at the account of previous effort try that because for every amazingLes Miserables , there is a dreadfulCats . Some shows simply are n’t made with a good enough tale to transition into a cinematic experience , yet they are forced into that hole anyway .

There are some amazing musical comedy that have been turned into just as groovy moving picture . Because of that , there will be more shows getting placed onto the big screen as films in the new decade , which is great as there are some tremendous musicals that seemingly lend themselves perfectly to that environment . However , hopefully , this X will see some smarter choices take place as there are still some red herring around Broadway and the West End that should be stave off at all costs . Within this leaning , we will take a look at 10 dissimilar musicals , ranking five that require to be made into cinema , and five that should be avoided at all cost .

Need: Hamilton: An American Musical

When it come to musical comedy that should get made into movies , the one most people will go to isHamilton : An American Musical . The show is a multi - time prize winner and has become one of the most sing - about display with tickets proving to be very surd to come by .

The show that really direct Lin - Manuel Miranda to a different level of fame has an first-class story . concenter on Alexander Hamilton and licit chronicle , there is plentifulness of material that could puzzle out well in a film here . With edgy , rap lyrics that are slightly different from the traditional mode melodious would aid this appeal to a wider interview .

Bad Idea: American Idiot

Popular ring deform their back catalogues into musicals is becoming quite the collision as of previous , and it is something that Green Day chose to do . Their euphony provides the backdrop forAmerican Idiot , which has proven to be a fairly pop musical since opening .

However , that does n’t imply it will read into a hit picture . When motion-picture show are made sing music from a legitimate artist , they be given to have a more worldwide collection than Green Day . While the set are fabulously popular , this would only appeal to a niche securities industry , and most fans of the band are rockers who are n’t desperate for a musical in their lives .

Need: The Book Of Mormon

The Book Of Mormonis another incredibly pop musical theater that would be everlasting to be adapted into a film . Seeing someone pop up to say " hello " on the silver screen would dead work on with this being a compelling and charming story that is still relatively New .

The author of the musical in reality createdSouth Park , with Trey Parker and Matt Stone knowing exactly how to create something for that mass medium . The musical is witty and has some fantastic funniness , all while providing a satisfying message , which would easily convey as a film .

Bad Idea: Joseph And The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat

Joseph And The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoatmight be a very popular melodious that is fun and upbeat , but it would not make a very serious movie . The musical comedy ’s story is far too wild and crazy to be contained into a potentially entertaining flick .

While it has more of a structure thanCats , the story is quite a crazy one which would n’t really be the most interesting moving picture imaginable . The songs are fun to spill the beans - a - long with , but that is why this is a melodic , and why it has n’t had a movie adaptation .

Need: Miss Saigon

While the old example of musical theater that require to be made into movies are fairly modern musicals , Miss Saigonis a classic . It has amount and fit countless times over the years and has always remain popular amongst audiences .

The story which is place during the Vietnam War is an incredible one , and the fact that only certain locations can hold this due to the rigid size is a great example of why it should be made into a movie . Being able to do the set perfectly with all the contingent that has always been destine would allow this narration to be secernate to perfection .

Bad Idea: We Will Rock You

The euphony of Queen apparently bring itself utterly to any sort of environment . Whether that be a rock concert , a musical , or a movie . We have seen thatWe Will Rock Youhas become a rattling winner as a musical , but that does n’t signify that we want a movie version of that .

TheBohemian Rhapsodymovie that Queen fans got was perfectly complete . It tell the story of the band and brought in the music as well , and say the storey that the melodious does would go bad to ever possibly live on up to those awesome levels of lineament .

Need: Dear Evan Hansen

Dear Evan Hansenhas burst into the world of Broadway recently and has quickly become a firm fan favorite . The medicine and lyric were create by Oscar winners Benj Pasek and Justin Paul and the euphony and story involved here really would work dead in a film environment .

The melodic hits a heavy and emotional subject as the main fibre suffers social anxiousness that leads to him produce a lie that affects an intact community follow the felo-de-se of a schoolfellow . It is a darker story in comparing to many musicals , but it is one that would really link well with a wider audience if it was turned into a movie .

Bad Idea: Starlight Express

A musical theater that features the cast all rolling around on rollerskates should be something that yell " NO " to any potential pic ideas . Starlight Expressis a neat musical that is a ton of play to watch , and seeing the actors vaporize around the degree is an amazing experience .

However , that same experience can not really be put into a movie , and therefore the entire draw of the musical would be lost on the silver screen door . Some great shows are perfect for the stage and this is one of them , but please , do not make this into a picture !

Need: Wicked

It is in reality quite hard to believe that this has n’t happened already . Wickedis one of the most well - known musical comedy with some unbelievably recognisable songs . There have always been rumors of this possibly becoming a motion-picture show and it seems that one daytime down the line that is sure as shooting going to chance .

It puddle sense though as it tell the story of the Wicked Witch ’s backstory , take a new twist on the popular movie . Because there is already an established movie existence for this musical to slot into , there is no reason this could n’t be a major hitting on the flatware screen .

Bad Idea: Avenue Q

Avenue Qis essentiallySesame Streetfor adults . It is puppets that whistle and trip the light fantastic toe about adult topic that are sure enough not for kids , which is why this would probably not render well into a film . When cinema are made using marionette ( which is rarified anyway ) , they tend to be targetted towards a jr. interview .

Because that is n’t possible with the cloth of this musical , it is unconvincing that there would be a desire for it to ever be made . It is a Tony Award - win musical , proving that it is for certain a major hit , but that does n’t mean that it is going to be a fantastic film .

NEXT:10 Killer Dolls Who Are n’t Chucky Or Annabelle

A collage image of Luke Skywalker in A New Hope

Chronicle Ending Explained - How Andrew Is Stopped In The Superhero Movie

Ben Affleck as Christian drumming his hand on the table while talking to Cynthia Addai-Robinson’s Marybeth in The Accountant 2

JosephandtheTechnicolorDreamcoat_Prod_2400x1256 Cropped

Hamilton

American Idiot

The Book of Mormon

update-2 Cropped

bohemian rhapsody

Evan Cropped

Starlight Cropped

Wicked the Musical ensemble

Aveneue Q Cropped

Movies