Related
tiddler ’s Play ’s notorious killer dollChuckyhas now been voice by two great actors , Brad Dourifand Mark Hamill , but who act the role better ? Sometimes a character becomes so intimately key with a particular actor , it ’s almost impossible to conceive of anyone else ever taking over the part . That ’s more often affiliate with live - activeness roles , but in the showcase of Chucky , it ’s also true . It ’s a chip unmated that Dourif ’s career trajectory took him from an Oscar - nomination forOne Flew Over the Cuckoo ’s Nestto voicing a skanky - mouthed dolly , but either way , he ’s terrific at it .
Of course , successful franchises run to last everlastingly now , and individual people do n’t . multitude die , the great unwashed retire , people get disturbed of act the same role , it happen . What makes the fact that Hamill played Chucky in 2019’sChild ’s Playremake specially odd is that Dourif has done none of those three things . He most recently voice Chucky in 2017’sCult of Chucky , and is set to render for Syfy ’s upcomingChucky telly series . Yet , due to a quirk in the dealership ’s right wing situation , MGM was capable to move in front with a remaking anyway , complete with a Modern thespian playing Chucky .
relate : Chucky kill His Own Mother ( But Not In The youngster ’s Play Movies )
Still , that should n’t be carry against Hamill , as Dourif was n’t interested in being part of the remake , since creatorDon Mancini ’s original franchise is continue . Hamill was offered a coolheaded role , take it , and even expressed nervousness publicly about take over such an iconic horror scoundrel after Dourif made the grapheme his own . That all read , did Hamill do to undecomposed his herald ?
Child’s Play’s Chucky: Who Played the Role Better, Dourif or Hamill
While it may not seem fair to judge Brad Dourif ’s intact run as Chucky againstMark Hamill ’s one moving-picture show , one form of has to do that , as Dourif does n’t get a ton of personal line of credit in the original picture . For most ofChild ’s Play1988 ’s running time , Chucky really is n’t shew follow to life , as an attempt to leave it a bit unreadable if what Andy is saying is real . With that caution out of the room , it ’s fourth dimension to get down to business .
Hamill ’s Chucky spokesperson is a lot less sinister and human - vocalize than Dourif ’s , but that ’s by design , as the fresh Chucky is a bird control by a malign AI , while the classic version is a skirt possessed by a serial killer . Dourif ’s Chucky part is also much more high up - pitched and squeaky , while Hamill ’s is softer and tolerant , even when doing evil affair . Hamill ’s Chucky is belike creepier for that reason , as most of the time , it sounds misleadingly friendly , while Dourif ’s Chucky does n’t usually set about to hide his homicidal intentions .
On the other helping hand , the fact that Chucky ’s voice is human have him far more subject of expressing utmost emotions like rage and pain , head to a much more dynamic rescue . He ’s also more sadistic , as while Hamill ’s Chucky will kill people , Dourif ’s might torture them first . Chucky seems more like his own part when playact by Dourif , while Hamill ’s can sometimes find more like a plot gimmick , but again , that ’s partly the resultant of theChild ’s Playremake ’s writing . At the remnant of the day , both doer stand out at the peculiar version of Chucky they ’re given to play , but Dourif ’s version is simply more memorable , funny , and menacing . Therefore , Dourif gets the victory .
More : Child ’s Play : Chucky ’s Human Name Was Inspired By Three Real Murderers
