Related
The Statute of Secrecy is the wizarding world ’s endeavor at protecting themselves against muggles and any recoil should as if by magic become commonly known . We ’ve all heard about what can find when muggles are armed with the truth . The Salem Witch Trials go away a black Saint Mark in history .
Because of that , witches and thaumaturge joined together to make and espouse a crew of rule . These rules are design to protect both thaumaturge and muggles . But not all laws make sense , as demonstrate by some of the things we ’ve seen during our time withHarry PotterandFantastic Beasts . Here are perhaps the ten items that make the least amount of sense .
The Pureblood Resistance
You might be surprised to hear there , but back when the Statute of Secrecy was put into place , there were several pureblood household who resisted the law . Specifically , the Malfoys were the most vocal in their opposition .
You see , they had ties to higher class muggle families , and they had gotten quite used to all the fringe benefit that add up with that association . They were n’t prepared – or unforced – to lose those benefit . This fact is probably a little confusing and comeback - visceral since you ’d think that purebloods would jubilate in the constrained distancing between muggles and thaumaturge .
Harry’s Trial
As far as exercise for the puzzling nature of the Statute of Secrecy , or how easy abused it can be , we postulate to look no further thanHarry Potter and the edict of the Pheonix . Here , we see Harry go on a full trial for do magic in front of a muggle .
Harry performed trick in front of one ( or two , depending on how much she really view ) witnesses . The first is Dudley , who is related to Harry and already knew that he was a virtuoso . And the 2nd was Mrs. Figg , a squib . Performing magic in front of these two would not matter as a breach , and yet it is n’t fetch up once during the trial run , imply that it was n’t a magnanimous bargain ? It ’s a moment odd .
Vague Dress Guidelines
We ’ve all see the fashion wizards and witches wearing apparel . It ’s the variety of thing that would get the attention of most muggles . So , naturally , there ’s a clause in the Statute of Secrecy covering how thaumaturgist and witch should dress when around muggles . This actually makes a lot of sensory faculty .
Unfortunately , those guidelines are slightly undefined and thus are n’t incredibly helpful for those that did n’t grow up see muggle fashion . So the termination is something that ’s still comparatively obvious and standout . It kind of shoot down the purpose of the law .
Magical Creatures Fall Under This Statute As Well
The Statute of Secrecy is a monolithic stage set of laws and clauses . In fact , it actually encompasses most laws about keeping sorcerous beings – from wizards to hob – out of the sight of muggles . This makes sensory faculty at first glimpse , but the more you think about it , the crazier it gets .
For instance , all sorcerous creatures are cover within these police force . Even those that wo n’t read or follow said practice of law . That makes affair a turn more complicated , putting even more obligation of the champion that see a charming being – while not automatically having any of the training .
Keeping the Secret, Even From Spouses
There was a period of time of time in which the Statute of Secrecy was even more strict than it is now . fancy the humankind show during theFantastic Beastsmovies ; witches and no - majs were leave zero interactions . That ’s essentially how it was at one point in time with the British laws as well .
Now they grant for a enchantress or mavin to reveal the truth to the spouse . But that was n’t always the case . This was sure to please the purebloods since it would be severe to marry somebody that you would have to shroud your nature from .
No Enforcement Spell Around the Muggle Prime Minister
Fans ofHarry Potterare well cognisant that there are two Prime Ministers . One is for the Ministry of Magic , and the other is the muggle Prime Minister . The two ministers blab out with the Ministry , one have license to reveal the truth to the muggle one .
There are no spells or spell placed upon the Muggle Prime Minister . The assumption is that they will never speak of it – for fear of face harebrained . This is also a figure with an immense amount of power , so this seems like a speculative decision . After all , what ’s to stop them from seek to start a new witch hunt ?
How To Help and Protect Muggles?
One of the major premises behind the Statute of Secrecy is that it protect muggles from enchantress and wizards . This would only use to those that are willing to comply with the jurisprudence , which is in reality a problem .
We see duringHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallowsthat witch and thaumaturgist were promote to step up and protect the muggles around them , by casting protective magical spell and the like . This is a set more hard to do when they must do it unnoticed . Perhaps a war clause should be added in to admit easier protective covering during super severe moment ?
Squibs
Perhaps the most frustrating problem with the Statute of Secrecy is that it does n’t seem to take Squibs into account . Where do they fall , in wish to these laws ? Back when there was no integration allowed , were they earmark to be with champion ? With muggles ? Or neither ? We ’re so disoriented ( and a little turn concerned ) .
There also do n’t seem to be that many rights or fear , when it comes to Squibs . They basically seem to be ignored in the jurisprudence and eyes of the Ministry .
The Methods of Tracking Underage Magic
The method acting of trail nonaged conjuring trick is perhaps the most confusing – and easy abused . Apparently , the trailing is less precise than one might imagine . Otherwise , Harry never would have been blamed for the legerdemain that occurred within his muggle home . You would think that they ’d be forced to come up with a better way of get over their students and their conjuring trick . This imprecise method does n’t seem to work , and theoretically , a student in a mavin family could easy practice magic at home and just have the Ministry assume that it ’s the adults within the home .
And while we ’re at it , how come up they do n’t seem to mind if children use magic before the age of eleven ? We ’ve seen Harry lose dominance – though he had a expert reason for doing so . We imagine he ’s not the only kid to get put in a post that would cause control emergence . Does the Ministry typically allow exceptions , or is Harry that exceptional ? That scarce seems fair if that is the case .
Rappaport’s Law
Rappaport ’s Law is the law add to the Statute of Secrecy in 1790 . This was the infamous law that squeeze crone and wizards to totally separate themselves from no - majs . This is a law specific to America , but it ’s still a baffling natural law . We read what caused it – all the tension in America made it insecure for magical beingness at that time . However , it is also extreme .
Especially when one considers the fact that the law was n’t repealed until 1965 . This seems like an awful that should n’t have get going on for nearly as long as it did .
NEXT : Harry Potter : 10 Things About Gringotts That Make No sentiency
