Related
When it comes to the Earth ofHarry Potter , everything seems so magic and superior to muggle life that the fandom would much rather be sorted into a Hogwarts House and play Quidditch than deal with mundane things like traveling via car or airplane . But how many would - be wizards really take the meter to consider the wizarding economic system , especially the many things about wizarding money that make zero sense ?
It ’s cute to turn over paying for a wand with gold coin or riding a hair curler coaster to access your underground vault beside a bad-tempered goblin , but in real liveliness , many of the adorable prospect of wizarding money really are n’t hardheaded .
Who Pays People?
From the employees aboard the Hogwarts Express to the people who exercise for the Ministry of Magic to Hogwarts teachers themselves , how do witches and whizz make money in the world ofHarry Potter ? We never take heed about how much Harry ’s tutorship run at Hogwarts and there ’s no manner it can be free . Harry does n’t have to pay to board the Hogwarts Express , and we do n’t really hear about taxes being collected .
If these services are all just part of being a wizard , that ’s overnice , but if income is still expect , then all wizards with jobs have to be paid by someone .
The Weasley Home And Income
Many a buff has puzzled over this one . You live in a world satiate with thaumaturgy , yet your sign looks like a giant volaille coop about to fall over . Why do n’t the Weasleys just utilize magic to reinforce their home and make it structurally sound ? It makes no sense for them to take currency to restore it when we see hag and wizards transfigure , good luck charm and otherwise witching just about everything under the sun .
Even taking Gamp ’s Law of Elemental Transfiguration into history , why not just metamorphose shingle from , say , acorns ? The law itself seems to be violated with various spells like Aguamenti anyway and it seems like it was merely created as justification for wizarding poorness . And why are n’t thaumaturgist pay a living wage ?
Gold Coins Are Impractical
Why would you carry around heavy coins for all of yourshopping needswhen you could carry light paper or cotton – or better , to magically exhibit your account rest with the tip of your sceptre ? Do goblins in reality transfer a cluster of coins from one hurdle to another for unmediated deposits ? That seems like it would take a bunch of time and energy , peculiarly puff all of those coins from one vault to another through the burrow system .
Digital money is one of the many advanced things thatmuggles seem to have over the wizards . Are wizards not even allow for to denounce online ? If they can , how do they do it ?
Costs Of Things Don’t Add Up
If you pay up attention to the prices of items in the wizarding domain , it becomes clear that the costs of things do n’t add up rather speedily . While a brace of Sickles for a potable sound about correct , charging more for textbooks than a wand indisputable does n’t .
Even if you were purchasing expensive college textbooks , a book for 9 Galleons make zero sense in a world where something as precious as a sceptre costs 7 Galleons . Ludo Bagman offers 5 Galleons for a joke wand when a single Galleon is a huge heap to the Weasley family , whose Gringotts vault is all but bereft of them . Just what is the reliable value of a Galleon with so many incompatibility ?
Monetary Value Is Silly
If you roll in the hay that it take on 17 Sickles to make a Galleon , 29 Knut to make a Sickle and 493 Knuts to a Galleon … then you know it make up even less sensation for students at Hogwarts to not have a maths class since they ’re run to expend all of their time adding up these idiotic coin . It makes zero horse sense to have such random values assigned to the coins , making them even more unmanageable to use than they are by weight alone .
Even if wizards can count their coins using illusion somehow , it still seems cockeyed to make each coin ’s value something that ’s difficult to round up , not to mention the worry it would cause for clerk dispensing variety back .
There’s One Bank
Can you envisage having to zip all the way to England just to go to the bank ? Granted , you may apply the Floo web or a Portkey to travel much more apace , but how inconvenient to not just be able to visit a banking concern in townsfolk .
It seems rather archaic for an origination to not branch out a bit since it was plant in the 1400s , specially give the universe booms , wizarding community around the earth and the phylogenesis of money itself . Why should the only bank be site in England , anyway ? And why does it have so many mines to salt away things in when a simple magic spell can make a bag have eternal room ?
Goblins Run The Bank
Whilegoblinsmight be great at hoarding money and keeping it safe ( except when they ’re not , as was aptly demonstrated in the final Word of God ) , they surely hate necromancer a plenty . Is it really a great idea for them to be in charge of all of the money in the wizarding world if they might adjudicate to flip side one daytime ?
It also makes no sense for a Polyjuice Potion to not be discover the consequence someone walks into Gringotts . WhileHermionedidn’t get away with it as she ’d hoped , she came close . Why were there no magic demodulator spells to protect everyone ’s business relationship ?
Muggle Money Is Re-Circulated… How?
Hermione ’s parent are able toexchange muggle moneyfor wizard money at Gringott ’s , which seems plausible enough , but then their muggle money is circularise back into the muggle world . How is this done ? Do goblins actually use electronic funds transfers or enter the muggle man somehow , or do they air wizards into it ? Who do they puzzle out with to get the money back into muggle hands ?
The rule has always been that electronics can act up around magic , which is silly enough , but if it ’s true , then how is it transplant ? Some fans speculate that it gets clear on to squibs somehow but it ’s never really explained .
Why Can’t Money Just Come From Magic?
In the Scripture , we ’re never given the full laws of transfiguration , and while it relieve oneself sentience that one ca n’t make something out of nothing , what would stop someone from transfigure turnips or charming Cheerios into money ? It hardly seems unsufferable , and while leprechaun amber is known to go away , surely there are spells that could make money that ’s been magicked into existence more lasting .
Perhaps there are anti - magicking magical spell in position to prevent the exchange of false money , but they ’ve never been mention before . If we can use a mere marker to essay counterfeit money , it would seem as though mavin would have some form of safeguard in place as well .
How Did Sirius Buy That Firebolt?
Fans constantly wonder how a convicted felon on the run was able-bodied to access his Gringott ’s account and purchase an expensive broom for his godson . Did the hob just not bat an middle when it come to Sirius wanting to make a leverage , and if so , how did Sirius even get the money out or expend it in the first place ?
Also , why not make anything like the Firebolt with magic ? From wands to textbook to really anything necessary , why ca n’t it be made with magic to avoid having to use money altogether ? If the ingredients are there , should n’t it work just as cooking the wizard way of life does ?
NEXT : Harry Potter : 10 screaming Ways The Wizarding World ’s thriftiness make No Sense
