Related
Bringing up any topic come to toStar Warsis a surefire elbow room to set yourself up for a earthly concern of argument , yet there ’s always an unavoidable debate over whether Luke Skywalker or Rey was the better protagonist . Their individual trilogy might have different perceptions surrounding them , but both of these heroes are mostly accepted by the fanbase .
However , there is definitely only one of these two who deserves the title of being the apex protagonist of the serial . For this listing , we ’ve for the most part considered the young Luke Skywalker , only slightly take into account the older one . We ’ve also concentre on in - universe force and overall character of their characters to pick our victor .
Emotional Moments: Luke
Every protagonist needs to have a good-hearted quality to them that make up the viewer beginning for their journey , and that comes through sustain minute that hit mightily in the feels . While the subsequence trilogy had more of these in quantity for Rey , Luke had the quality ones .
In fact , just the scene where he offer goodbye to his beginner is one that places all the understanding in the world towards Luke . Scenes depicting the deprivation of his loved ones have a more echt feel where Luke is involved , and fans tend to commend these more .
Instant Likability: Tied
There ’s nothing to carve up the two characters in this area , seeing as both of them had launching where the viewer like a shot took to them . Luke and Rey were designate as being lower socio-economic class workers in desert planets , and both of them had a vernal appeal .
The fear with which they find oneself themselves in their journey , and the adorkable timber they had , where they made friends strictly because of their favorable nature , made Luke and Rey the perfect protagonists to jump thing off with .
Enemies Faced: Rey
Sure , Luke did have the Empire to face , and he did get on jet and use all variety of weapons to fight these enemies , but Rey was the one show pretty much all on her own and still coming out on top . This made her enemies deadlier , regard as Rey did n’t generally have back - up .
Rey also stick out the full brunt of the punishment from the likes of Kylo Ren , Snoke , and Darth Sidious , while Luke did n’t have as many straight - up match - ups . The First Order also seemed to have more adept henchmen than the Empire ’s relatively clumsy lot .
Comedic Moments: Luke
The original trilogy reallywas much funnierthan the eternal sleep of the films , and we have Luke to thank for this . While Han was the funniest of all , Luke himself had a nice guy entreaty that made him have an clumsy energy that was played for laugh .
There was an effort to replicate that with Rey , but it just mat rehash for the most part , alternatively making her look clueless . With Luke , you got the horse sense that a blowy time was to be had , as his laughable scenes had a relatable feel .
Friendship Dynamic: Luke
This is another country where the serial endeavor to place Rey in the same place as Luke was , but it really is a no - brainer that Luke ’s moral force with his friend was much great . His friendship with Han is one pairing that has n’t been gibe in all ofStar Wars , and he even had great relationships with C3PO and Leia .
Part of the magical spell of the original movies was seeing these grapheme interact , with Luke being the right way at the centre of thing . Rey ’s main friendly relationship was with Poe , and even that was chiefly centered inThe Force Awakens , with her latter flick only have her meet her friends sparingly .
Firmer Resolve: Rey
You might need to argue that Luke faced temptation from both Darth Vader and Palpatine to go to the dark-skinned side , but he did have the backing of his supporter and Obi - Wan to avoid turning that manner . On the other hand , Rey was broadly seen on her own , with even mentors like Luke having lost their resolve .
The fact that she had a romantic involvement in Kylo Ren yet still defied the drear side think of that Rey had that unconditioned goodness that assured TV audience they could rely on this supporter to see them through . She also suffer torture at the hands of each villain and managed to keep the light .
Story And Character Development: Luke
Supporters of Rey tend to say she shined well considering the stuff she had , but there ’s no enquiry that Luke ’s storyline was of the highest quality . This had the outcome of making the protagonist himself seem like the genuine deal .
Watching Luke develop from a farm boy over to a Jedi passe-partout who realise in experience and maturity is what make something as fantastical asStar Warsseem so grounded . The light and darker aspects of the reference both complement Luke well , all due to the timbre storyline he was provide .
Fight Scenes: Rey
The continuation trilogy managed to take the good out ofthe video recording game seriesto make the fight scenes seem large - than - liveliness . Rey ’s finical scenes were the best of these , with her battles with the likes of Kylo Ren and Palpatine being exceptionally cool .
It ’s a pretty bounteous deal to have a protagonist pogy out great engagement scenes , as viewers tend to remember these sequences more , contributing to the aura around the main role . For this ground , Rey search like a million bucks when you regard her combat skills .
Chemistry With Villains: Luke
Darth Vader would never have come across asthe awesome baddie he wasif he did n’t have a protagonist like Luke face him ; the same go for Luke ’s moral force with Palpatine . The fact that his conflict with these guys was n’t restricted just to strong-arm fight , but had an aroused involvement , made them deserving following .
Rey ’s angle with Kylo Ren take a sudden romantic twist inThe Last Jedi , following which it was more of a making love narrative than a grinder - scoundrel moral force . Her showdown with Palpatine lack that ecstasy - factor because it seemed shoehorned rather than earn like Luke ’s did .
Winner: Luke
We ’ll go so far as to say that Rey is a passably well - rounded character , but it ’s pretty clear most of what we figure her go through was the templet that Luke had put beforehand . He just had an originality surrounding him that will always place him higher than any otherStar Warsprotagonist .
From his likability lineament to his type growth , and peculiarly his chemistry with the rest of the characters , Luke ’s completeness in his use as the main agonist stand for that he ’ll always be the first name fan think of when considering who the leave character ofStar Warsis .
NEXT : Rise of Skywalker : Top 10 Star Wars Movie Heroes , Ranked
