Marriage Story
Noah Baumbach’sMarriage Storyis a nude and intimate looking at at the small things that precede up to one big thing ; divorce . It ’s tell from the perspective of each person in the man and wife , Nicole and Charlie , who fall very fervently in love once but whose pairing has become like the ocean shore ; systematically , relentlessly , and reliably beat against by every unfulfilled promise , every accusatory look , and every trouble not intercommunicate .
There are no hoagie and there are no villains in this story , and there are no easily identifiable fault to find with these two people . With every situation that arise , from the selection of lawyers , to the give-and-take of custody over their young boy Henry , they are proven to be fallible hoi polloi trying to make the best of a mournful billet . Below are 5 reasonableness why we ’re on his side , and 5 ground why we ’re on her side .
WHY WE’RE ON HIS SIDE: CHARLIE IS A DEDICATED FATHER
Charlie may be consumed by his theater employment a mess of the time when he ’s in New York , but that does n’t hold back him from being a consecrated father . Throughout the film , he fights for fond custody of his Logos Henry , despite the fact that Nicole want to live halfway across the body politic with him .
Charlie does n’t particularly like Los Angeles , but he makes the trip back and off between his dwelling house and hers to check that he ’s a part of Henry ’s life . He recognize that he need to be an important figure in Henry ’s formative long time , and that the divorcement proceeding will take a toll on him . He did n’t have a great kinship with his don , and so never wants to let his son down .
WHY WE’RE ON HER SIDE: SHE GAVE UP HER DREAMS FOR HIS
Prior to match Charlie in New York , Nicole was an actress just beginning to make her chump on Hollywood . She was in a teen motion picture that receive a lot of traction , mostly due to her performance , and she was parlaying her newfound notoriety into more workplace . This included furcate out into theater , which took her to New York , where she saw Charlie ( a young player and music director ) perform and experience an insistent draw towards him .
During their courtship they were inseparable , and she finally moved to New York to star in his dramatic play . While she was still technically acting , her performances were under his scrutiny and therefore control . They discussed peradventure moving back to Los Angeles where she could take up her film calling , but ultimately his Broadway dream eclipse hers .
WHY WE’RE ON HIS SIDE: SHE NEVER COMMUNICATED
From the very opening fit inMarriage Story , we get the mother wit that Nicole is n’t very good at communication . She may be a near actress , but that ’s reading someone else ’s dialogue . She often rarely has anything to say herself , and we ’re lead to trust that ’s becauseCharlie is so controlling .
However , it ’s difficult to know if you ’re being a controlling partner if your spouse never communicates with you . Much of the semantics in their divorce legal proceeding boil down to the fact that they never fully discussed matter to each other ’s expiation , which left elbow room for doubt and confusion . She may have want a lot of their relationship to go differently , but she never communicated it in a direction that Charlie could sympathize .
WHY WE’RE ON HER SIDE: HE CHEATED ON HER
One of the great blows to the sanctimony of marriage is unfaithfulness , no matter how it happens to attest . Over the trend of the film , we determine out that Charlie rip off on Nicole with a theater companion , and it induce their already tense relationship to get even more constringe by resentment .
Charlie maintained that he only stepped outside the marriage bed because they had n’t been intimate in over a year , forcing much of the incrimination on her . In reality , his own ego - absorption with his theatrical report had press her aside , to the tip that being faithful to him in that way was wholly unappealing .
WHY WE’RE ON HIS SIDE: SHE INHIBITS THEIR SON’S GROWTH
Charlie readily admit that Nicole is a wonderful mother because she enjoy to toy with their boy Henry . Any time of the Clarence Shepard Day Jr. that Henry require to scrunch down with his cup of tea of statuette , she gladly lays on the floor and help him behave out his most inventive fantasy adventures .
However , she also has a bad habit of reinforce him unnecessarily , such as for doing things he otherwise does n’t desire to do . When he does n’t want to drop time with Charlie , Nicole whispers she ’ll get him a present if he complies . Charlie knows that long - condition , this sort of reward will be negative for Henry ’s growth when he does n’t always get a loot for doing something .
WHY WE’RE ON HER SIDE: HE USED HER FOR HIS WORK
For much of their marriage , Charlie ’s theatre of operations piece of work took precedence . Nicole did n’t realize just how much until she understood how much of her own personal identity got swallowed up in it . Her name recognition amplified the notoriety of his plays , and she became confident that he never loved heras much as she loved him .
She explain candidly to Nora , her divorce attorney , that at first she was flattered that someone with his intelligence would pay her any attention . But then she order artistic type like him " lavish you with attention in the root until you become a mum " and then they forget you until you ’re useful again . When she lands a pilot program in Hollywood , he conceive he ’ll get half the money she ’d make from it .
WHY WE’RE ON HIS SIDE: HE NEVER HAD A REAL FAMILY
While Nicole has a close - pucker kinsfolk that deeply cares about her endure in Los Angeles , Charlie does n’t have any biologic family in New York . He ’s built an " urban family " in the theater residential district to take their place , and they put up much of the funding he take during his divorce .
One of the most poignant things we learn in the filmis that Charlie ’s childhood was full of alcohol addiction and ferocity , which makes it all the more important to him that the family he builds be stable . He does n’t require to lose the atomic unit he ’s made with Nicole and Henry , because he recollect there ’s still hope they can be glad .
WHY WE’RE ON HER SIDE: HE BROKE HIS PROMISES
A healthy marriage is establish on communication , money plant , and trust . Partners have to learn to find a Libra the Scales between their own wants and desire and that of their spouse ’s . If they can convey openly and aboveboard without judgement , these sorts of compromise can be reached .
Charlie spends his wedding to Nicole making and breaking promises , which gnaw at the Lunaria annua and trustingness between them . She no longer believe him when he says he ’ll let her lineal one of his plays one Clarence Shepard Day Jr. , or that they ’ll spend more clip in LA with her family . She no longer sees a future tense with him when she understand he ’ll never stop lying to her , however accidentally .
WHY WE’RE ON HIS SIDE: HE WAS BLIND-SIDED
The film makes it vindicated that had Nicole not filed for a divorcement , Charlie would n’t have . Being far too focused on his theater career and fatherly duties , he seemed surprised that his wife wanted to separate . When the papers are process to him in her female parent ’s kitchen , he ’s trance off guard , but not as off guard as he will be .
From the moment he arrives in LA to set out the proceedings , he ’s blind - side by their elaboration . He has difficulties discover the right sound counsel , and switches attorney several times . The advice he ’s given is incredibly perplexing , and every time he tries to do what he think is the correct thing , it turns out to be the wrong thing as far as the divorce unconscious process goes .
WHY WE’RE ON HER SIDE: HE NEVER SUPPORTED HER AMBITIONS
She ’s always been his cheerleader , even though by her own admission nothing ever obtain him down , and he never feel " defeat " like she does . But nevertheless , when he father a esteemed Cary Grant for several hundred thousand clam that will fund his theatrical projects for five years , she cheers him on .
This is a projection of the form of support she ’d love to receive from him , but never does . Charlie did n’t see her as separate from himself , and usurp she was happy in her life because he was felicitous in his . But he never once thought to require if she had any ambition of her own , or if she require to quest after film acting again .
NEXT:8 Best Roles Adam Driver Has Taken On ( Besides Kylo Ren )
