Onward
The much - hype gay character reference inOnwardis the latest example of Disney ’s trouble when it comes to spoil representation in their movies . As time transfer , so too does Hollywood , if typically a whole lot tedious than many hoi polloi would like . That ’s certainly been the case when it comes to mainstream representation of the LGBTQ community on the freehanded screen in recent years . Queer - code persona have been around since the early daylight of cinema , long before filmmakers like Gus Van Sant , Todd Haynes , and Gregg Araki pioneered New Queer Cinema in the later twentieth century . Yet , relieve for the exceptions proving the rule , it ’s only been over the last two decades that movies target general audiences have featured queer leads and/or key supporting player .
Obviously , there ’s still a whole lot of improvement to be made in this regard , and nowhere is that more evident than when it comes to Disney . The Mouse House has yet to release an animated picture show boast an openly - queer protagonist , even after fanscampaigned for years for Elsa to get a girlfriendin last November’sFrozen II . And while they did recently let in a gay booster cable ( namely , Frankie A. Rodriguez ’s student choreographer Carlos Rodriguez ) on theirHigh School Musical : The melodic : The Seriesfor Disney+ , they also barely catch into red-hot waterfor movingLove , Victor- a spinoff of the queer high school fixed storage - comLove , Simonreleased by Fox in 2018 - from Disney+ to Hulu over concerns about it being " too ripe " for the service .
Related : Love , Simon Controversy Highlights a Big Disney+ Problem
Disney ’s half - hearted drive at LGBTQ delegacy in their films in particular has becoming a run antic by this degree ; eventheFrozen IIHonest Trailercalled attention to it , referring to the supporting eccentric Honeymaren ( Rachel Matthews ) as being"The Blink And You ’ll escape It Gay Character That Disney Will dab Itself On the Back About . “That might seem a second harsh to some but , frankly , the studio apartment brought this on itself .
Disney Has A Lot Of “First” Gay Characters, All Disappointing
There ’s been a trend in late years of Disney pic being hyped for include the " first " queer character(s ) , only to let down with the genuine answer . This arguably started in 2016 withFinding Dory , which in short featured what many interpret to be a sapphic mates visiting the Marine Life Institute ( where much of the film choose place ) . Unfortunately , rather than taking a definitive stance on the issue , director Andrew Stanton ward off confirming or deny anything , saying"They can be whatever you want them to be . “A yr afterward , it came to light the fictitious character LeFou ( Josh Gad ) would be canonically gay in Disney ’s live - actionBeauty and the Beast . Frustratingly , however , this amount to small more than a brief present moment where LeFou trip the light fantastic with another man .
Disney has since released a handful of movies featuring explicitly singular persona , beginning with last year’sAvengers : Endgame(where cobalt - music director Joe Russo plays a jocund man grieving the loss of his married man ) and continuing on to December’sStar Wars : The raise of Skywalker , when Commander D’Acy ( Amanda Lawrence ) kisses another charwoman during the Resistance ’s victory celebration near the end . trouble is , much like LeFou ’s terpsichore , these scenes are barely even a few second gear long and easy to miss if you ’re not listening too carefully or , inRise of Skywalker ’s typeface , paying attention to the background . These moments are pandering at substantially and too trivial to be meaning as anything more than small incremental whole step .
refer : Star state of war : Rise of Skywalker ’s Lesbian Kiss ( & Why It ’s Not Enough )
no-good to say , that goes double for the evenly - hype " first " LGBTQ character reference in a Pixar movie inOnward . The vista in question take place when the motion picture ’s jumper lead Ian and Barley must disguise themselves after being take out over by a mates of pig , including Officer Spector , a cyclops constabulary officervoiced by Lena Waithe(herself , an openly mirthful actor - writer ) . Spector has a few lines and in short note having a girlfriend before the fit terminate and she fundamentally vanishes from the rest of the picture show . It ’s yet another model that begs the head : why is Disney even including these pitiful moments of " representation " at all ?
Disney’s Poor Representation Is Good For The Global Box Office
The answer , as it so often does with Hollwood , has to do with the money side of show business . Modern - 24-hour interval Disney congratulate itself on being at the front of the packwhen it come to being sensitiveto way out of intimate orientation , race , and gender , and aspires to reinforce that figure of speech by incorporating LGBTQ characters in their movies . At the same fourth dimension , they ’re always implicated about doing anything that could damage their films ' commercial prospects . This include the likely blowback to them announcingeither the protagonist or a lead characterin one of their liberation ( be it a Pixar , Star Wars , MCU , or Disney Animation feature ) is openly funny . or else , by only include supporting and otherwise underage mirthful character , Disney is ( theoretically ) able-bodied to reap the benefit that come up with the good press without cast out too many filmgoers in the U.S.
Worldwide , it ’s also a tricky place . A tidy sum of countries do n’t support LGBTQ rights andOnwardwas actually bannedin post like Kuwait and Saudi Arabia ( while still screening in other area of the Middle East ) for include Officer Spector at all . Disney ca n’t simply not screen their tentpoles in these countries either , given how vital external grosses are to most of their movies ; case in point , Frozen IImade $ 973 million of its $ 1.45 billion total outside the U.S. whileRise of Skywalkergrossed more internationally ( $ 559 million ) than domestically ( $ 515 million ) . By making these scenes of queer representation so short and inconsequential to the narrative , Disney is able-bodied to well blue-pencil them out and still let go of their films without them when necessary .
Related : Oscar Isaac Blames Disney Overlords For No Finn - Poe love affair
What Disney Must Do For Representation In The Future
If there ’s a flatware facing to Disney ’s underwhelming overture so far , it ’s that these scene have nevertheless helped to further normalise LGBTQ representation in mainstream films . Ideally , in the future tense , Disney moving picture will make on this by continue to include one - off moments like these while at the same metre making existent leads queer and flesh its faggot digest players out into three - dimensional fibre . If they do n’t , the studio risks getting more of a negative response than a positive one every sentence they harbinger yet another " first " or similar milestone in LGTBQ representation for one of their upcoming films . Arguably , that ’s already started to happen ; neither the intelligence aboutRise of SkywalkernorOnwardseemed to engender hullabaloo the room Disney clearly thought they would .
Thankfully , the studio is take steps in that direction . It ’s already been confirmedThe New Mutants(which Disney acquired in its Fox purchase ) feature aqueer dearest news report between two of its leads , while Marvel Studios and Chloé Zhao ’s upcomingEternalsis reassert to let in thefirst gay MCU movie superhero and buss . Obviously , that ’s not an end in and of itself , and one surmise the candy kiss inEternalswill still be brief enough to be edit out for its theatrical rill in certain country . Even so , the close Walter Elias Disney catch to offer full - go down on representation for the LGBTQ community in their films and not just blink - and - you’ll - lack - it stuff and nonsense like Officer Spector ’s scene inOnward , the better .
NEXT : Every Pixar Movie Releasing After Onward
Onwardis available for streaming on Disney+ in the U.S. beginning April 3 .
