Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl
In the mid - to - late 2000s , thePirates of the Caribbeanfranchise was on top of the world . The first motion picture , The Curse of the Black Pearl , was n’t expected to be any good because it was free-base on a theme park ride . But it deform out to be a lot of fun , surprising moviegoers everywhere .
However , as the series went on , the critical response got more and more disconfirming until eventually , it was in the same sordid conference asTransformers . So , here are five reason why thePirates of the Caribbeanfranchise merit to be return another shot , and five why Disney should just let it die .
DESERVES ANOTHER CHANCE: Pirate Movies Are Really Fun
On a conceptual level , thePirates of the Caribbeanfilms are just a innovative , big - budget response to definitive swashbuckler movies likeCaptain Blood , Treasure Island , andThe Crimson Pirate . Those movies are a lot of fun , and no one ’s making plagiarizer movies anymore .
There is a ton of potential for a fun moviegoing experience inDisney writing a $ 200 million balk for a pirate adventure movie , just as long as it does n’t strike into the pitfalls of focusing on nonsense like zombi spirit and sea monsters and Jack Sparrow talking to hallucination of himself .
LET IT DIE: The Public Has Turned On Johnny Depp
Due to someunfortunate allegationsthat have come out against Johnny Depp in the last span of years as he goes through ugly divorcement proceedings with Amber Heard , public sentiment of the role player has soured .
Depp has been carrying thePirates of the Caribbeanfranchise on his shoulders since 2003 , so the fact that the public has turned on him is a pretty exonerated indication that thePiratesmovies take to stop .
DESERVES ANOTHER CHANCE: The Franchise Could Thrive Without Jack Sparrow
A huge part of why thePirates of the Caribbeanmovies worsen over the yr is that the charm ofJohnny Depp ’s Jack Sparrow schtickwore off . impart the flamboyance and theatricality of Keith Richards ’ on - stage persona made for a fun quality in the first span ofPiratesmovies , but it have old cursorily .
If Disney prune necktie with Depp , and thePirates of the Caribbeanmovies blockade being beholden to Jack Sparrow , then the dealership might be able to thrive .
LET IT DIE: The Story Has Been Dragged Down By Supernatural Elements
The fun of the firstPiratesmovie was that it was a swaggering adventure on the high seas . That ’s why it ’s a shame that the subsequent movies receive more and more bogged down in supernatural element like cuss and the undead and wizardly MacGuffins .
Making a greatPiratesmovie today would expect stripping away the knotty mythology and drop all the extrasensory facet to just make a straightforward swashbuckler movie . But if a writer was going to do that , then they might as well just write an original pirate movie and start their own franchise .
DESERVES ANOTHER CHANCE: The Old Cast Could Be Reunited
IfX - Men : Days of Future Pastproved anything , it ’s that a franchise in need of improvementcan benefit from bringing back fan - pet shape membersthat have been drop for a while . InPirates of the Caribbean ’s pillowcase , that would be Orlando Bloom as Will Turner and Keira Knightley as Elizabeth Swann .
It was fun to see Will and Elizabeth inDead man Tell No Tales , but they only appeared very in short , and they had nothing to do with the main storyline necessitate Jack . If they ’re going to do a reunification , they should do a real reunification .
LET IT DIE: Each Sequel Has Been Worse Than The Last
The Rotten Tomatoes score and Metacritic rating of eachPirates of the Caribbeanmovie has been systematically lower than the last . Those situation do n’t offer a definitive metric unit for pass judgment movies , but this does give an indication of the franchise ’s down flight . The Curse of the Black Pearlstarted things off on the right base with a sport risky venture fill with prominent action set pieces and comic relief that landed .
However , as the series went on , each movie captured less and less of that magic . The most late first appearance , drained Men Tell No Tales , was the cinematic combining weight of incoherent drivel .
DESERVES ANOTHER CHANCE: Gore Verbinski Had An Interesting Vision For The Franchise
ThePiratesfranchise take off to go downhill when Disney got free of Gore Verbinski . His initial trilogy was easily the unattackable run in the series .
presently , Joachim Rønning is slat to return to helm the series ’ 6th installment , but he already prove he make subparPiratesmovies withDead Men Tell No Tales .
LET IT DIE: The Zeitgeist Has Moved On
A big mistake that studio make is wear that a franchise that was once democratic will always be pop . ThePiratesmovies once dominate the conversation surrounding blockbusters . In 2007 , the most pop moving picture theatrical role were a disparate group including Jack Sparrow , Shrek , Optimus Prime , Jason Bourne , and Barry B. Benson .
However , in 2008 , the moviegoing world was introduced to Tony Stark , and the expression of movie house was interchange . Now , superheroes find the box office . By contrast , thePiratesfranchise is a dinosaur that Disney refuses to allow to go nonextant .
DESERVES ANOTHER CHANCE: Disney’s President Of Production Agrees That The Pirates Movies Could Be Better
Talking about a potential sixthPirates of the Caribbeanmovie , Disney ’s prexy of production Sean Bailey said , “ We require to bring in a novel vigour and vitality . I get laid the [ pirate ship ] moving picture , but … we want to give it a rush in the pant . ”
It ’s not easy for a luxuriously - ranking administrator to intromit that one of the franchise owned by the studio apartment they work for needs a kick in the pants . The fact that Bailey said that is a promising sign for thePiratesfranchise ’s hereafter .
LET IT DIE: Disney’s Had Enough Chances
After the first couple of motion-picture show vex the franchise off to a strong start , Pirates of the Caribbean : At World ’s Endjoinedthe pantheon of disappointing threequelswith a bloated plot , cringeworthy sense of humour , and bucketloads of unneeded exposition . After that flick , Piratesfans hold Disney one more fortune withOn Stranger Tides .
Then , when that let down , they gave Disney another chance withDead Men Tell No Tales . And that was even more disappointing . At a certain percentage point , Disney ’s had enough luck to give this franchise a kick in the pant , and they ’ve blown them all .
NEXT:10 Things The Pirates Of The Caribbean Reboot Needs
