Related
George Lucas never intend forReturn of the Jedito be the ending of theStar Warssaga , but as he got older and fans ruthlessly laid into the prequel trilogy , he never got around to making the sequel trilogy . When he trade his company Lucasfilm to Disney and the studio be after to make their own sequel trilogy , Lucas includedhis treatments forEpisodes VII , VIII , andIXin the slew to dulcorate the pot .
However , the Mouse House decide to do off with Lucas ’ vision for the end of his own story and alternatively enrol J.J. Abrams to beat the dead horse of the original trilogy . So , here are the 10 best idle concepts from theStar Warssequel trilogy .
No Redemption For Ben Solo
When Colin Trevorrow was attached to direct and co - writeEpisode IX , he wrotea script entitledDuel of the Fatesthat Kathleen Kennedy was unhappy with . In this script , Ben Solo did n’t achieve buyback at the death . Despite the best efforts of Luke , Obi - Wan , and Yoda ’s Force trace , Ben would ’ve been too far gone to return to the light side of the Force .
Ben ’s spark was telegraph as a redemption discharge from the first and he did irreclaimable things like aggregated execution , so it would ’ve been both less predictable and more justifiable not to pay off him at the conclusion of the trilogy .
Visiting The Whills’ Microbiotic World
The prequel trilogy was about the birthing of the Empire and the original trilogy was about the reign and declivity of the Empire . To up the ante , the subsequence trilogy needed to be about something more . In its last physique , it ’s just about the upgrade and descent of another imperium that uses all the same tech as the previous one .
But according toan interview that James Cameron direct with George Lucas , the original design for the continuation trilogy was to plunge into “ a microbiotic human race ” where the Whills live . The Whills control the Force and intercommunicate with the midichlorians . It sound waste , but it also sounds wildly original – something that waslacking in Disney ’s sequel trilogy .
Luke’s Lightsaber Kills A Porg
The Porgs were fundamentally the continuation trilogy ’s Ewoks ; the cutesy animals that were only created to deal merchandise . While younger watcher adore them , older viewer cynically rejected them . Early inThe Last Jedi , some Porgs can be hear play with Luke ’s discard lightsaber . There ’s a fear that they ’ll accidentally ignite it and one of them will die , but it ultimately does n’t pass off .
Some unused concept artistry shows the lightsaber leaf blade going through a Porg ’s head . This would ’ve been a great moment of dark humor in a movie that often gets bogged down in its lofty philosophical approximation .
Leia Is A Full-Blown Jedi
After revealing Leia to be a Skywalker inReturn of the Jedi , George Lucas wanted to show off her Force sensitiveness in the sequel trilogy .
InThe Last Jedi , Leia flew through space like Peter Pan , and inThe Rise of Skywalker , there was a shoehorned - in flashback to Luke education Leia with an arbitrary reason yield for why she gave it up . In Lucas ’ reading of the sequels , Leia could ’ve been a full - blown Jedi .
Moving On From The Jedi And The Sith
At the conclusion ofThe Rise of Skywalker , Emperor Palpatine declares himself to be “ all the Sith , ” and Rey declare herself to be “ all the Jedi , ” before triumphing over evil and bring peace back to the galaxy . In Colin Trevorrow ’s original script forEpisode IX , Leia encourage Rey to give up her hobby of becoming a Jedi to instead become “ something newfangled . ”
The dichotomy of the Jedi and the Sith clearly does n’t solve , as it keeps go to empires and superweapons and genocide . It would ’ve been an interesting stopping point to the Skywalker saga to see the galax move past those archaic religion .
Stormtrooper Laundry
InThe Art of Star war : The Last Jedi , there ’s a storyboard for the scene in which Finn and Rose infiltrate the First Order ’s fleet . They sprain a corner on the ship and find a bunch of Stormtrooper suits hang in a laundry elbow room , drying off after a wash .
TheStar Warsmovies have never wanted us to take the Stormtroopers too seriously as a terror , and often include sight gags that undermine their power as a military force out . This would ’ve been a ok example of that .
Luke Dies In Episode IX
George Lucas keep theStar Warscast informed of his program for the sequel trilogy , andaccording to Mark Hamill , Lucas did n’t intend to kill off Luke Skywalker in the heart of the trilogy .
Luke still died in Lucas ’ reading of the trilogy , but it was n’t until the very ending . Hamill explained , “ I happen to roll in the hay that George did n’t belt down Luke until the end of [ Episode]IX . ”
R2-D2 Is Telling The Whole Saga
earlier , George Lucas planned to finish theStar Warssaga definitively with a fanfare - forward to the remote future in which the only survivors of the story ’s event are the droids .
It would be reveal that the whole saga has been recounted to a Keeper of the Whills by R2 - D2 . This would ’ve been a nice way to attach everything together in a neat arc .
Kylo Ren Meets Tor Valum
When J.J. Abrams took overEpisode IXand turned it intoThe Rise of Skywalker , he resurrected Palpatine to be the movie ’s adversary . In Colin Trevorrow’sDuel of the Fatesscript , Palpatine was n’t the chief baddie , and he remain deadened . But he did appear in a holographical subject matter he ’d recorded to be played in the consequence of his dying .
rather , Kylo Ren would travel to Vader ’s castle on Mustafar , get hold this message , and be directed to Palpatine ’s master , Tor Valum . This character ( who may or may not have been Darth Plagueis ) was described as a 7,000 - year - old Lovecraftian beast .
Luke Skywalker Has A Wife And Kids
One of the most controversial point of theStar Warssequel trilogy was Luke Skywalker ’s characterization as a bitter solitary who could n’t worry less about the Jedi or free the galaxy of evil . Even Mark Hamill was disappoint by where Rian Johnson took Luke ’s electric discharge inThe Last Jedi .
Originally , Luke was get going to be characterized closer to his Expanded Universe vis-a-vis , with a wife and kids ( who may or may not have been Mara Jade and Ben Skywalker ) . Timothy Zahn , author of theThrawnseries , said that theStar Warssaga was intended as a generational thing , withthe prequels focus on Anakin , the original trilogy focus on Luke , and the sequel focusing on Luke ’s children .
NEXT : Star Wars : 10 Best idle Ideas From The Prequel Trilogy
