Star Wars: The Chosen One Should Never Have Been A Jedi

Anakin Skywalker was theStar Warsfranchise ’s Chosen One - but it ’s becoming increasingly clear that he should never have been a Jedi . When Qui - Gon Jinn discovered Anakin Skywalker on Tatooine inStar Wars Episode I : The Phantom Menace , he fleetly realized that he was the long - preach Chosen One . According to Qui - Gon , Anakin was designate to bring balance to the Force .

It ’s been 20 years sinceStar Warsintroduced the concept of the Chosen One , but curiously enough Lucasfilm is only now beginning to explain it by . Claudia Gray ’s novelMaster & Apprenticefinally definedthe choose One divination , break a sanctified text that seems to raven the Jedi Order itself . " A opt One shall come , " the prophecy read , " born of no father , and through him will ultimate equaliser in the Force be restored . "

Related : Star Wars Reveals Why Qui - Gon Jinn Was n’t On The Jedi Council

But what exactly does it imply to bring about balance in the Force ? Little by little , Star Warsis beginning to ply an reply to that motion . In doing so , it ’s suggest that the fate of the entire galax went haywire when Anakin Skywalker bring together the Jedi .

The Chosen One Is An Agent Of Balance

One matter ’s for sure : Anakin Skywalker made a pretty miserable Jedi Knight . He never managed to control his belief , and in verity the Prequels chart his descent into the glum side of the Force;The Phantom Menaceexplores Anakin ’s fear , Attack of the Clonessaw him knuckle under to choler , and he gave in to hatred inRevenge of the Sith . But he was n’t an ideal Sith either , as evidence when he choose to dare the dark side and protect his Word Luke from the Emperor ’s Force lightning . It’simpossible for a Sith to become a Force Ghost , so his demonstration at the final stage ofReturn of the Jediproved that he had been redeemed .

Why would the Chosen One be such a miserable fit for both the Jedi and the Sith ? An important account has been offer by Cavan Scott ’s recentStar Warsaudiobook , Dooku : Jedi Lost . It bring out an ancient Jedi mantra , that suggested the Jedi of onetime had known something that had been draw a blank by the Prequel Era . It seems that " balance " is well understood as a distinct vista of the Force , separate from light and dark . " We call upon the three , " the mantra states , " abstemious , dismal , and balance unfeigned . One is no big than the others . Together , they unite , restore , center , and regenerate . We walk into the light , acknowledge the dark , and find balance within ourselves . The Force is strong . " This mantra suggests that the pick out One is not an agent of light or dark , but rather of balance , and thus Anakin was never intend to be either a Jedi or a Sith .

Anakin Was Born Outside Of The Republic

Interestingly , the Prequels themselves offer circumstantial grounds to support this approximation . Qui - Gon Jinn discovered Anakin on the planet Tatooine inStar Wars Episode I : The Phantom Menace , and he was shocked at how powerful the tyke was in the Force . " Had he been born in the Republic , we would have identified him early , " he told Anakin ’s female parent Shmi , " and he would have become a Jedi , no doubt . " Ironically , though , Qui - Gon - the Jedi most aware of the living Force - still failed to need a wide-eyed question : whywas Anakin birth outside the Republic ?

relate : Star Wars : George Lucas ’ Sequel Trilogy Would Be As Controversial As Disney ’s

Anakin Skywalker was intend as a Messiah parallel , create after the Biblical design of Jesus . In Christian divinity , nothing about the circumstances of Jesus ' birth was a concurrence ; every element was according to the will of God . In exactly the same elbow room , Anakin ’s parturition was allot to the will of the Force . That means the Force had deliberately chosen to ensure Anakin was brook outside the Republic . Though Qui - Gon did not see it , this subtly signified that the Force did not want Anakin to be taken to the Jedi as a child . And when the Force finally did bring a Jedi to the Chosen One , it was the one Force substance abuser who could school Anakin in the ways of equilibrium .

Din Djarin and Ahsoka-1

Qui-Gon Jinn Would Have Trained Anakin In Balance

It ’s important to understand that Qui - Gon Jinn was no average Jedi . He and his own sea captain , Count Dooku , numbered among just a smattering of Jedi who were familiar with theancient Jedi prophesies , and who looked to the mode of honest-to-goodness for guidance . The Prequel Era Jedi believe that the prophesies were dangerous , a potential route to the dark side because they were an attempt to exert mastery of the future rather than glimpse it as the Force bequeath ; they fail to consider the opening that the prophesies could themselves be part of the Force ’s will . ButQui - Gon know well , which is why he alone of all Jedi was face for the mark of the prefer One .

Qui - Gon also had a unique understanding of the construct of balance . His exposure to old Jedi teachings think of that he grow uncomfortable with the Jedi ’s theatrical role in the Republic , which he believe compromise their service of the Force . As a issue , one draw - in mirthful sawQui - Gon Jinnlaunch himself across the star on a quest . He was guided to a world unattackable in both side of the Force , a natural ecosystem that was held in a perfect , beautiful Libra . There , Qui - Gon commence to infer balance as something that had to be pursue in its own right , and prepare himself on a path that would defy the Jedi Council many times .

This is the Jedi Master who was guided to Anakin Skywalker ; a insurgent with a causal agency , a man who see beyond the classic light and glum duality . It ’s true that Qui - Gon ab initio search to have Anakin become a Jedi , but the Council formally forbade him to take Anakin as his Padawan . Had Qui - Gon hold out the Battle of Naboo inStar war Episode I : The Phantom Menace , he would have been thrust to quit the ordination to train Anakin Skywalker . Thus the Force had position in movement event that would have ensured Anakin was not civilize as a Jedi Knight at all ; rather , he would have been trained as an agent of balance , as the Force had intended .

George Lucas with A New Hope imagery v3

relate : The TRUE Disney Star Wars Story ( Finally Revealed By The CEO )

This , then , is the ultimate calamity ofStar Wars . It is the direction of the Sith to attempt to dominate the will of the Force , to bend it according to their own desires . The turn point in galactic story was thus the bit when a Sith Apprentice , Darth Maul , make out down Qui - Gon Jinn in battle on Naboo . From that consequence on , the will of the Force had been suborned to the will of the Sith , and the lot of the Chosen One had been crucify . But , as the honest-to-goodness mantra states , " the Force is strong . " The Sith may have managed to scotch the Force ’s plans for a meter , but that can not last forever , because they are warring against the Force - and the Force naturally tilts towards balance .