Related
The reveals from the novelization ofStar warfare : The raise of Skywalkerhave confirmed that Disney has no solid design forStar Wars . This is despite the existence of theStar Wars Story Group , which is suppose to plan thing out and keep allStar Warsmedia reproducible with a broader vision .
There have been signs of this mussiness in Disney’sStar Warsbefore . Directors J.J. Abrams and Rian Johnson seemed to have comparatively costless reign to make their movies however they want . Johnson tookThe Last Jediin adifferent direction than what Abrams originally envisionedafterThe Force Awakens , and then a number of option inThe lift of Skywalkerseemed to movecounter to the directionThe Last Jediwas going .
link : Star war : The Rise of Skywalker ’s Most Epic Plot Holes
The novelisation ofThe ascent of Skywalkertakes this to a newfangled level by spilling huge details that were left out of the motion-picture show . Rey ’s father is a failed Palpatine clone , not his son . Palpatine is a successful Palpatine clone . Rey and Ben ’s kiss was n’t romantic , it was about gratitude . And this is just some of what ’s in the novel .
The problem is n’t that Rae Carson ’s novelisation does n’t oppose the movie perfectly . That ’s normal , as a novel can drop more time on the story , going into detail a moving picture would cut for pacing reasons . The novel are also usually based on earlier versions of the hand , before changes made while shoot and editing the movie . The job is that , rather than adding some profoundness or more background toStar Wars : The Rise of Skywalker ’s story , it feels like Disney is walk big instant back and yield explanation that should have been in the movie in the first billet .
The revival of Palpatine as a clone is one of those thing . In the picture show , Palpatine ’s retort was covered in the possible action crawl and a quick scene with the rebel reacting to the news with the now - infamous pedigree , " Somehow , Palpatine has returned . " No explanation of how or why - he ’s just back . In the novelisation , there ’s a moment where Kylo Ren realize the cloning machines at employment on Palpatine . This could have been a shot in the motion picture , but it wasn’t . There ’s a pile of Snoke bodiesto imply cloning , but nothing draw the connection to Palpatine himself . The only explanation of Palpatine ’s return is a handwave : “ The obscure side of the Force is a pathway to many abilities some would consider abnormal . ”
Every major reveal in the novel comes across like this , raise the same question of why it was n’t in the movie . Had Disney been following a solid design forStar Wars , these problem would n’t be plaguing the novel and there would have been few holes in the pic . While thenovelization ’s postponement may not have been enough timeto make these change and retcons , the amount of explaining it does feels like scrambling to unsex things in chemical reaction to the electronegative reception thatThe Rise of Skywalkerreceived .
Next : Star Wars 9 ’s Script Revealed Clone Palpatine ( But The Movie Cut It )
